“You’re Mean Now, Mommy!”: What to Expect When You Shift from Permissive to Authoritative Parenting
- Bethany Blaine
- Jan 8
- 4 min read
If you’ve recently changed how you show up as a parent and started hearing:
“You’re mean now.”
“You don’t let me do anything anymore.”
“I liked you better before.”
This post is for you.
You’re likely standing in one of the loudest, least talked-about transitions in parenting:
the shift from permissive parenting into authoritative leadership.
This phase often feels worse before it works.
And without orientation, many parents retreat right here — not because they lack love, but because they lack steadiness.
This post will help you understand why this phase feels so destabilizing, what’s actually changing beneath the surface, and how to stay grounded without reverting or escalating.
Why Kids Revolt When Parenting Changes
Permissive parenting usually comes from deep care and intention.
It prioritizes:
emotional attunement
flexibility
minimizing power struggles
keeping the peace
And for a time, it works out okay, until the cost shows up — as exhaustion, resentment, and emotional volatility.
What permissive systems quietly teach a child’s nervous system is this:
My emotions determine outcomes.
Think of it as a byproduct, not an intentional belief instilled. When feelings consistently override structure, the nervous system learns to escalate rather than regulate.
As children grow, this shows up more clearly:
negotiations turn into power struggles
disappointment becomes dysregulating
frustration tolerance stays low
So, when parents shift toward authoritative parenting — where warmth remains but boundaries become predictable — children feel the loss of control immediately.
That loss is not actually dangerous, but to little nervous systems, it's a worthy threat because it is unfamiliar.
And nervous systems react loudly to unfamiliar.
Why the Transition Gets Messier Before It Gets Steady
When parents begin holding clearer structure, children often respond with:
increased defiance
stronger objections
louder emotional expression
This is the part where many parents wonder if they are failing as a parent. You are not.
It’s a recalibration phase. and not many people want to discuss it openly.
Your child's nervous system is testing for outcomes:
“Is this structure real — even when I’m upset?”
The most important part of this transition isn’t smoothing over everything.
The most important part of this is consistency without confusion.
And that’s where many parents struggle — not because they don’t know what to do, but because they haven’t been supported in who to be while doing it.
Why Parents Drift Toward Permissive Parenting (Even When It Drains Them)
Most parents don’t choose permissiveness consciously.
They arrive there honestly, authentically.
Many are correcting their own childhoods (especially those raised with fear-based, dismissive, or authoritarian models.) They vow to do the opposite, so empathy becomes the priority.
But empathy without structure doesn’t eliminate distress — it redistributes it onto the parent.
Over time:
emotional awareness gets mistaken for emotional authority
naming feelings replaces guiding behavior
parents become emotionally responsible for everyone in the room
Burnout lowers boundary capacity.
Giving in feels easier than holding firm.
And approval often gets confused with safety.
But children don’t need parents they never feel upset with.
They need parents who are safe to be upset with — without the adult collapsing, bargaining, or disappearing emotionally.
The Long-Term Cost of Permissive Systems
The cost of permissiveness isn’t immediate.
It’s a delayed strain on the parents AND children.
Over time, families often experience:
ongoing power struggles
emotional volatility as a baseline
conflict without repair tools
parental resentment later in life
children who struggle with frustration tolerance
Most importantly, children may feel anxious without knowing why.
Because when no one is clearly holding structure, the child's nervous system stays alert to everything.
Predictability is calming.
Ambiguity is not.
What Authoritative Parenting Actually Changes
Authoritative parenting is not authoritarian.
It doesn’t rely on fear, punishment, or emotional shutdown.
It is:
warm and firm
emotionally attuned and decisive
compassionate and boundaried
During the transition, things often feel harder before they feel steadier:
reactions get louder first
emotional discomfort lasts longer
younger children may get more physical
older children push back verbally
parents often feel worse before children settle
This is the moment most parents need support.
Because authoritative parenting requires something that permissive parenting does not:
the parent’s nervous system staying intact under pressure.
What’s Changing Beneath the Surface
As authoritative leadership settles, children slowly learn:
feelings are allowed — behavior is guided
adults can handle big emotions without collapsing
rules remain predictable, even under stress
safety comes from structure, not control
This is how self-regulation develops.
But it requires parents to stay present through discomfort — not to eliminate emotion, but to remain emotionally intact while guiding behavior.
That steadiness is a learned skill.
And without internal structure, parents often revert — not because they disagree with boundaries, but because pressure exposes where their own system lacks support.
This is where The Conscious Shift Guidebook comes in.
It isn’t a parenting manual.
It’s a stabilizing framework.
It helps parents orient to their values, build internal steadiness, and apply structure without collapsing or hardening when things get loud — especially during periods of change.
How You Know It’s Working (Before It Feels “Better”)
Change doesn’t happen overnight.
But there are early markers worth noticing:
shorter emotional episodes
faster recovery after conflict
more post-conflict closeness
increased honesty
less emotional whiplash
The household becomes predictable again — not through control, but through felt safety.
If You’re Being Called “Mean” Right Now
This phase doesn’t require more wins.
It requires steadiness and support for the parent nervous system, too.
Being called “mean” often means:
“This structure is unfamiliar — and I’m adjusting.”
When parents remain regulated, children don’t need to be in charge.
They get to be kids — held by adults who can handle the weight of leadership without fear, collapse, or resentment.
The future doesn't rest on your shoulders; it rests on your nervous system. Regulation is transmitted before its ever taught.
Comments